Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Politics and Hypocrites

"Outrage" a new film directed by Kirby Dick is a documentary that is based on the work of Mike Rogers who examines prominent, closeted gay politicians and their very public, active campaigns, and appalling voting record against the LGBT community. Rogers actively works to expose these closeted gay politicians with research and true reporting through his blog website. The list of secretly gay politicians is overwhelming and surprisingly long, as is their poor voting record against gay rights. A popular argument against the film is that these men deserve their privacy. I have to disagree, much to the contrary of the Washington Posts article titled 'Outrage' Drags Politics' Conservative Wingtips Out of the Closet. The article basically argues that there is mostly no real substance behind the evidence. But who needs substance? There were numerous sources who told, in person, detailed accounts of their encounters with prominent government representatives with descriptions of intimate regions of their bodies, homes, decorations, etc. Although the bulk of the evidence is circumstantial, it doesn't mean that it is readily disposable. The fact of the matter is that these politicians, gay, closeted, or not, are making a huge (or lack thereof) contribution to LGBT rights in order to prove to themselves and the public that they are not gay. If they wanted, they could make serious, positive change for themselves and for the rest of the LGBT community that they covertly belong to. If all politicians who are closeted came out and openly admitted they were gay, the issue of gay rights would no longer be an issue. In order to keep the popular vote and reaffirm their straightness, they must keep their dirty little secrets locked away and promote traditional family values. The media also pushes a lot under the rug in order to protect their right wing allies, or to avoid legal confrontation (except in the case of Larry Craig). It's a vicious circle of deception, and the public deserves to know about the private lives of their representatives in order to decide who is trustworthy and who is not. Some will say that personal opinion or religious beliefs shouldn't or don't affect the way that representatives make policy, but it absolutely does, especially when there reality is scewed by the psychological effects of a double life. They are undeniably traitors to their own selves and traitors to their voters. We deserve to know if our lawmakers are hypocrites because it affects us directly through their policy making.

2 comments:

  1. I'm kinda mixed on this. I agree with you that these politicians are hurting the people that they vote against and that yes it is horrible that they feel they can not identify with the gay community, if they are in fact a homosexual yet, I have to admit I don't think people's sexual identity is any one else concern.

    I am 100% for gay rights and have worked for groups like equality Maryland to get pro 8 voted no and been in equality marches before but, I do believe that a person's sexuality and identification is something they do not have to explain or say. In our society it be great if everyone could come out and be comfortable with themselves and strong but, sadly we don't live in a society where we can do that. It is understandable if they plan to stay in the closet and it was really rude that they were outed on a list instead of getting the decency to say it themselves. I think by creating a society where people can be open would help stop things like this happening. Not by writing a blog and presenting scandalous material even if these politicians are hurting others.

    I think the best way we can change this is why lobbying for strong politics that are pro-community and creating more understanding and awareness in our society.

    Do you really think that by lying about their sexuality they are untrustworthy? That's not very fair to say since you do not know why they choose to hide. Even tho I'm pro-gay rights I can't call them hypocrites because there is so much pressure and stress in our society esp. depending on what time period they grew up. The gay rights movement has only been around for 30-40 years.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Katie, in that any individuals sexual identity is no ones concern but their own. And I think it should be up to the individual to decide what information about themselves that they share with others.

    And really I think its silly to say that every homosexual is "hiding" until they "come out". Just because they don't talk about their sexuality, doesn't necessarily mean that they're hiding. No one has ever called out a heterosexual person and made them feel that they were being deceptive if they did not come out as/tell the public that they're straight.

    ReplyDelete